On October 22, 2018, Olivia Culpo posted a photo on Instagram of her and Danny Amendola at the beach with the caption, "New and exclusive rock hard 6 pack temperpedic (sic) ab pillow, boyfriend not included." A mere six days later, TMZ posted photos of Amendola getting a little too comfortable with a bikini-clad mystery woman. 

As expected, it didn't take long for the mystery woman's identity to be revealed – former Miss Malibu and current CBS4 Miami sports reporter, Bianca Peters. A source told Us Weekly that the pair "met the night before through mutual friends" and were just hanging out. "All their friends met up at the beach on Saturday, [October 27]. Bianca has no plans to hang out with Danny again. It was just a Saturday at the beach." The source added, "I don't think they hooked up," but you might have a similar reaction to Culpo after reading that. "Wow," she tweeted, in an apparent response to the seemingly scandalous photos. 

For her part, Peters wants no part of the drama. "Danny is new to Miami and Bianca had no idea he had a girlfriend. She is not in that world. She was a CBS journalist who is just starting her own media company," a source told E! News. The insider added"Now that she understands the situation, she has no plans to see him again. She does not want to be dragged into this."